Last in Their Class

“James S. Robbins is a very talented and prolific writer. His skill is very much in evidence in this fascinating new book…There are books one needs to read and there are books one wants to read. Last in Their Class is both.”
– Mackubin Owens, National Review

“James S. Robbins brings a refreshingly new perspective…. In examining the first century of West Point’s existence, Robbins presents a glimpse of the less-known side of West Point…. In captivating detail, Robbins traces the post-Civil War legacy of the men who continued the tradition of the Goat…. In the final analysis, Robbins provides a provocative insite into early history of West Point. The tradition of the Goat and the Immortals clearly demonstrates that academic performances is not a prerequisite for military success.”
– Col. Cole C. Kingseed, Army Magazine

“Engrossing study of the iconic Goat..interesting and informative…. Perhaps Robbins plans a sequel? Let’s hope so.”
– Tom Miller, Military Magazine

“While Robbins laments the modern demise of the meritocratic system of stigmatizing sutdents for low achievement, he also explores why and how the same audacity, individualism, and even occasional insubordination that earned a cadet low marks at school often later proved indispensable for officers in the real world on the battlefield. This is a much-needed and timely investigation into the nature of military leadership.”
– Victor Davis Hanson, author of A War Like No Other

“[A] well-researched work that skillfully links the threads of these individuals to the wars and othe revents in our nation’s history. Additionally, Professor Robbins does a great job in teaching readers about the educational methodology of West Point.”
– Tripp Bowles, The Virginian: Journal of the Pickett Society